Re: CCL:DFT & metal-metal bond distances



 Dear Peter,
    What you are seeing is normal when you use
    GGA (B3LYP, BP86, PW91...)  exchange-correlation functionals.
    These typically overestimate bond distances for molecules
    and lattice constants (in the case of solids).
    Now you have to be careful when you use quantum chemical
    ECP's with these calculations. The reason being, these ECP's are
    normally calculated using Hartree-Fock and therefore one has an
    incompatibility in the exchange-correlation...i.e. you have an Hartree-Fock
    ECP and a GGA exch-corr in the main calculation.  Its important to
    keep the theory levels consistent i.e. you should use a GGA
 
optimised pseudopotential if you're using that GGA in your main calculation.
    You could try this.
    In your case where you've been using ECP's in conjunction with your
 
DFT calculations, you should still see an over estimation. If you do get the
    correct answer its purely by chance. It would in some sense be the
    right answer for the wrong reason...
    Hope this helps
  -Niranjan
 At 07:50 PM 7/19/00 +0200, Dr. Peter Burger wrote:
 
 Dear CCLers,
 I got a question concerning DFT & metal-metal bond distances.
 With both B3LYP and the BP86 functionals I do observe siginificantly
 longer metal-metal multiple bonds compared to the experimental data
 (accurate) in geometry optimizations of dinuclear (tungsten &
 molybdenum) complexes, which have bond orders of 2. (M-M distance 2.72
 X-ray vs 2.88 A by DFT) I have done alot calculations with different ECPs,
 all electron basis for Mo, basis sets (double and triple zeta for the
 metal centers) but could not cure the problem. The complexes are
 dicationic and I am not including the anion so far.
 The calculations are done without solvation, i.e. in the gasphase.
 Comments? Anyone with an idea? Perhaps I should include point charges
 in the geom. opt. step?
 Many thanks in advance
 Peter
 ------------------------------------
 Peter Burger
 University of Zuerich
 -= This is automatically added to each message by mailing script =-
 
CHEMISTRY -AatT- ccl.net -- To Everybody | CHEMISTRY-REQUEST -AatT- ccl.net -- To Admins
 MAILSERV -AatT- ccl.net -- HELP CHEMISTRY or HELP SEARCH
 CHEMISTRY-SEARCH -AatT- ccl.net -- archive search    |    Gopher: gopher.ccl.net
 70
 Ftp: ftp.ccl.net  |  WWW: http://www.ccl.net/chemistry/   | Jan: jkl -AatT- ccl.net
 
 ___________________________________
 
Niranjan Govind, Ph.D.
 Scientist, Materials Science
 Molecular Simulations, Inc
 
9685 Scranton Road, CA 92121-3752
 Tel:   858-799-5337, Fax:  858-458-0136
 Email:  nxg -AatT- msi.com
 Web: http://www.msi.com