CCL: RE: W:Disclose your data, or not publish !



 Sent to CCL by: Valentin Ananikov [val__ioc.ac.ru]
 
 Sent to CCL by: "Chemical  Bond" [chemicalbond001|"|yahoo.com]
 
Everyday, tons of new publications come out.
 Would it be possible to develop a numeric criterion to estimate the quality of
 publications?
 Without clear criteria for estimating quality, clarity, impact and significance
 of the publications such discussions tend to be rather philosophical and
 useless.
 I am really interesting if there was any research addressing this problem?
 Best regards,
 Valentin.
 Valentin Ananikov
 Zelinsky Institute of Organic Chemistry, Moscow
 Russian Academy of Sciences.