CCL: Name of authors during review ...!!!
- From: Robert Molt <r.molt.chemical.physics:_:gmail.com>
- Subject: CCL: Name of authors during review ...!!!
- Date: Mon, 05 May 2014 08:14:49 -0400
Sent to CCL by: Robert Molt [r.molt.chemical.physics(!)gmail.com]
Clarification, pursuant to some private correspondence given to me:
the names I mentioned in my former email of great scientists (Dr.
Bartlett and Dr. Cramer) were mentioned NOT to imply that there is
something wrong with the higher esteem given to their names (my PhD
advisor and MS advisor, respectively!).
My point is simply that some rookie (me, for example) is not going to
have a bias in his favor for the same work as someone who has already
proven (him/her)self. I acknowledge this is not always a bad thing,
but
it defeats the point of meritocracy (success based on the specific
paper
and the paper alone, not anyone's past).
I am hugely biased if I see a paper written by Anna Krylov or Don
Truhlar. I am sure, in the recesses of my mind, I will *not* question
it half as much as I would a name I did not know. That's not judging a
paper on its own merits, its own logic.